See Asa at Microbiome & Probiotic R&D & Business Collaboration Forum - La Jolla, California 10/13/2025
February 22, 2023 By: Asa Waldstein

Animal Product Claims Under Increased Scrutiny

Takeaway -

Old social posts are “active” marketing

Claims made about animal products seem to have a lower tolerated “acceptance level” than human products. This is a friendly reminder to take another look at your animal product marketing because there may be forgotten risky marketing statements that can come back and “bite you” (I couldn’t help the animal pun).

Here is one example. These are obvious disease claims that should be avoided, but usually, this would not “tip the scale” into warning letter territory in a human product.

From warning letter: “… for dogs was designed and tested to boost your do’s natural defenses against the unique host of fungal, parasitic, viral, and bacterial pathogens that flourish in the desert southwest.”

No company is too small to be off FDA’s radar. This company has a very small web and social media presence, but they were still discovered and cited. Anyone marketing products online is “fair game” for enforcement. I write more about this here.

Seven-year-old social media posts are cited in this letter. Plenty of two- or three-year posts have been called out in warning letters, but a seven-year-old post is going way back. I ask, does anyone really look at these really old posts? In the eyes of the FDA, these are considered active marketing and, therefore, should be compliant. Here is a post about this.

Scanning old social posts is critical to any compliance “clean up” project I conduct. These forgotten old posts provide only risk and no marketing benefit.

Here is an old and relatively lower-risk example.

From warning letter: “From your social media website. On January 29, 2016 you posted: “Important information: frequently when pets first start showing symptoms of Valley Fever they do not register a titer and thus the reason for misdiagnosis and the wrong course of treatment. If your pet is showing any signs then start Desert Defense while you await the diagnostics!”

Disclaimer: The educational information provided here is for informational purposes only. Contact an attorney for specific legal advice. Rule #1 in compliance is to ensure marketing is truthful and not misleading.

Written by

Asa Waldstein
Asa Waldstein
Asa Waldstein is a 24-year veteran of the dietary supplement industry, with experience spanning manufacturing, marketing, and regulatory compliance. He is the principal of Apex Compliance, a software company dedicated to streamlining regulatory marketing compliance for the dietary supplement and natural products sectors. Asa also leads Supplement Advisory Group, a boutique consultancy focused on marketing risk analysis, labeling, and practical compliance strategies for websites and social media. Asa has helped oversee three FDA GMP inspections with no 483s and was honored with the 2023 AHPA Herbal Hero Award and the 2024 What's Up Supps Policy and Change Agent Award. He currently serves as Chair of the American Herbal Products Association’s (AHPA) Cannabis Committee, helping shape policy and industry best practices